Suffolk County Hamlet · Town of Smithtown · Suffolk County

Smithtown

A complete guide to living in Smithtown — real estate, dining, local life, and what makes this community worth knowing.

Hamlet · Town of Smithtown · Suffolk County

Historic Town Center With the Famous Bull Statue

Smithtown hamlet is the historic town center — home to the famous bull statue marking the founding legend, a genuine Main Street with real shops and restaurants, and the LIRR Smithtown station. This is a mixed community of older Colonials and post-war ranch homes on generous lots, with strong appeal to families seeking good schools and community connection.

The Smithtown Tap Room and Jewel (a local restaurant institution) anchor the community dining. Main Street has real independent character — not overdeveloped, not commercialized, just a genuine town center. The LIRR station makes this commuter-accessible. For buyers wanting a real town center with character and commuting access, Smithtown delivers.

This is straightforward suburban Long Island — good schools, good value, community spirit, no pretense. Buyers here are families with school-age children, professionals commuting to Manhattan, and people seeking authentic community without estate pricing.

Smithtown at a Glance

Character
Historic town center
Landmark
The Bull Statue
LIRR
Smithtown station direct
Main Street
Real independent shops + restaurants
Price Range
$600K – $1M
County
Suffolk

Market Snapshot

Smithtown real estate

Price Range $600K – $1M
LIRR Access Excellent, direct
Main Street Real, independent

Getting Around

🚂 LIRR (Smithtown) Walking distance from center
🚗 Penn Station ~50 min LIRR

Smithtown Buyer?

The Lenard Team knows Smithtown's authentic character and value positioning.

Get Home Value Schedule Consultation

Local Life

Where to Eat & Drink

The places that define the Smithtown dining scene — from local institutions to neighborhood favorites.

Dining data loading. Contact the Lenard Team for local recommendations.

Homes for Sale

Smithtown Listings

Live listings updated daily. Contact the Lenard Team for off-market opportunities.

Request Full Inventory

Featured Listings

Top of Market
274 River Road, Saint James, NY 11787
✦ Featured Listing
Single Family

$1,800,000

274 River Road

Smithtown, NY 11787

6

Beds

6

Baths

6,268

sqft

Set behind black iron gates and approached by a long sweeping driveway, this extraordinary all-brick estate is a rare offering rich in history, character, and timeless elegance. Originally built in 1905 and set on 8.95 picturesque acres along the scenic Nissequogue River, this landmark property captures the grandeur and old-world appeal of a bygone era while offering an incredible opportunity to restore and reimagine a truly special home. In addition to the main parcel, the property also includes an additional 4.5 acres of wetlands located across the river, creating an exceptionally rare and expansive setting. Steeped in history, the residence once served as a hunting and fishing lodge in the early 1900s and showcases exquisite architectural detailing and craftsmanship rarely found today. Once owned by famed actress Dina Merrill, the estate carries with it a remarkable sense of legacy and prestige. From the moment you enter, the home is filled with warmth and character, featuring impressive millwork, rich wood floors, spacious formal entertaining rooms, and elegant period details throughout. At the heart of the home is the magnificent grand ballroom with soaring ceilings and a stunning stone fireplace — an unforgettable space reminiscent of the estate’s storied past and ideal for grand entertaining. The residence also features a desirable first-floor primary bedroom suite, generously sized rooms throughout, a full basement, and a expansive detached garage. Surrounded by natural beauty and offering exceptional privacy, this remarkable property presents endless potential for those who appreciate historic homes and old-world elegance. Conveniently located just minutes from Long Island beaches, restaurants, shopping, and the LIRR. A truly rare and iconic North Shore estate waiting to be restored to its former glory. Offered in “as is” condition. Please note: Listing photographs reflect the home at the time the current owners purchased the property and do not represent the current interior contents. All contents will be removed prior to closing.

View Full Listing →

Browse by Price

Listing data sourced from Zillow. Contact the Lenard Team to verify current pricing and availability.

Your Smithtown Expert

Buying or Selling in Smithtown?

The Lenard Team knows Smithtown — the market dynamics, which streets command premiums, and when to move. Whether you are early in research or ready to make an offer, the right conversation starts here.

Ask about off-market listings. Ask about what has sold in the last 90 days. Ask what your current home is worth if you are thinking about moving up.

Get In Touch

JL
Jon David Lenard
The Lenard Team · Long Island Real Estate

Part of Smithtown

Explore the full Smithtown guide

← Back to Smithtown